If your engine and OEM permit either grade, 5W-40 is the safer, general-purpose choice for most modern passenger engines—better fuel economy, adequate high-temp protection in normal to warm climates, and usually compatible with modern seals. 5W-50 is recommended only when you have sustained high under-hood temperatures or heavy/high-RPM duty (track, towing in very hot climates, heavily modified/high-power turbo engines) and the manufacturer allows a higher high-temp viscosity.

Choosing 5W-50 when not needed risks slightly worse fuel economy and increased oil drag; choosing 5W-40 when 5W-50 is warranted risks insufficient HTHS protection and accelerated wear under extreme loads.

Final short answer (if you want one-line):
— Use 5W-50? Yes only for sustained extreme thermal/high-shear duty or engines with high clearances/older wear; No for normal daily driving, cold climates, or where OEM mandates 5W-40 or lower.

Inputs used / how to get the best-tailored answer

You provided a selection framework but no specific vehicle details. Where useful, below I specify the exact user inputs that would flip the recommendation. If you want a fully vehicle-specific single-line recommendation, paste:

• Vehicle: Make / Model / Year / Engine code
• Usage pattern: (Daily / Track / Towing / etc.)
• Climate: (min/max °C or region)
• Mileage/engine wear: (km/mi and condition)
• Manufacturer spec: (ACEA/API/OEM approval)

I proceed below with rigorous, science-based comparisons and clear criteria you can apply to your case.

Viscosity science overview (SAE J300 explained)

• SAE J300: the standard that defines motor oil viscosity grades. Grades have two numbers: “5W” (winter rating) and “40”/“50” (high-temperature rating).
  • “5W” — viscosity at cold temperature (measured by low-temperature cranking and pumping tests). Lower W number = easier cold start flow (better oiling on start-up).
  • “40” vs “50” — characterizes kinematic viscosity at 100 °C (and practical behavior at operating temperatures). Higher number = thicker oil at a temperature.
• Key derived properties:
  • HTHS (High-Temperature High-Shear viscosity): measured at 150 °C under high shear; correlates strongly with film thickness under bearing/rod loading and with protection under high load. Typical numeric ranges: oils formulated for API SN/CF often target HTHS 3.5–4.5 mPa·s for “40” class; “50” oils commonly target higher HTHS ≥4.0–5.0 mPa·s (varies by formulation).
  • Shear stability: resistance of the viscosity index improvers (VIIs) to mechanical shearing (chain breakage) under high shear. Poor shear stability → viscosity falls toward the base oil viscosity, reducing film at operating temperature.
  • Viscosity index (VI): how much viscosity changes with temperature. Higher VI = less change (desirable).

Technical comparison: 5W-50 vs 5W-40

(Assume both are high-quality synthetic formulations; differences are in high-temp targets, VI improvers, and additive dosing.)

Cold-start lubrication performance

• Both 5W-40 and 5W-50 share the same “5W” cold rating, so:
  • Cranking and pumpability at low temperatures are essentially equivalent if both meet SAE J300 5W tests.
  • Small differences may exist in dynamic viscosity below ~-20 °C depending on base oil and low-temp additives — but not due to the suffix (40 vs 50).

Implication: For winter / cold-start protection, neither grade has a practical advantage if both are true 5W oils.

High-temperature shear stability & film strength

• 5W-50:
  • Formulated for higher kinematic viscosity at 100 °C and typically higher HTHS, yielding thicker hydrodynamic/ELM (elastohydrodynamic lubrication) films under load.
  • Often uses more robust VIIs or higher base oil viscosity—better at maintaining film under sustained high temp/high shear (track, heavy towing, high-boost turbos).
  • Downside: more VIIs means potential for shear thinning if not well-formulated; premium formulations mitigate this.
• 5W-40:
  • Lower high-temp target and typically lower HTHS; adequate for normal duty and many high-performance street engines, but may approach limits under prolonged extreme loading.

Implication: If your duty includes sustained high crankcase temperatures (>120–140 °C oil temps under load) or extended high-load/boost periods, 5W-50 gives stronger margin against film breakdown.

Fuel economy effects

• Higher operating viscosity → higher viscous friction (pump and ring drag) → small but measurable reduction in fuel economy for 5W-50 vs 5W-40 under identical conditions.
• Typical magnitude: fractions of a percent to ~1–2% fuel consumption penalty depending on engine sensitivity and driving style.
• Modern low-friction engines tuned for 0W/5W lower-temperature grades will notice more effect.

Implication: If maximizing fuel economy matters (commute, city driving), 5W-40 is preferable.

Turbocharger / track stress protection

• Turbos: high bearing speeds + high exhaust gas temps demand stable film thickness and oxidation stability.
  • 5W-50 generally provides better oil film and bearing protection in high-exhaust-temp, high-RPM scenarios (especially older engines or modified turbos without modern cooling).
  • Oil coking and thermal breakdown risk depends more on base oil quality and additive package (antioxidants, dispersants). A well-formulated 5W-40 with proven high-temp antioxidants can still be excellent.
• Track: repeated high-RPM, high-load laps create sustained oil shear and higher bulk oil temperatures. 5W-50 increases safety margin for bearings and cams.

Implication: For frequent track use or high-boost turbo operation, 5W-50 is often the safer choice—if OEM allows.

Engine age and seal compatibility

• Older engines with increased clearances or worn bearings may benefit from the thicker high-temp film of 5W-50 (reduces noise, increases oil pressure).
• Seals: Most modern synthetic formulations maintain seal swell compatibility across 40–50 grades. However, some very old elastomers (nitrile seals in classic cars) may react differently to certain synthetic base stocks or higher additive concentrations—this is rare but possible.
• Cold leakage: No difference (same 5W rating). Warm leakage risk is usually lower with thicker oil, but if an engine relies on a very specific viscosity for pressure regulation (OEM-specified), deviations can affect PCV, valve cover gasket leak tendencies, or oil consumption.

Implication: For high-mileage engines with clearance, 5W-50 can reduce oil consumption and improve oil pressure; but check compatibility with OEM specs and seals.

---

Detailed comparison table

Property / Use	5W-40	5W-50	Engineering consequences
Cold-start (crank/pump at low T)	Same — both 5W	Same — both 5W	No practical difference for starting torque or initial film
Kinematic viscosity @100 °C (nominal)	Lower (targets around ~12–14 mm²/s for 40)	Higher (targets ~16–18 mm²/s for 50)	50 provides thicker bulk film at operating temp
HTHS (150 °C high-shear)	Typically lower (e.g., ~3.5–4.0 mPa·s)	Typically higher (e.g., ~4.0–5.0+ mPa·s)	Higher HTHS → better bearing/rod protection under load
Shear stability (VIIs needed)	Less VII need → potentially more stable	More/stronger VIIs → potential shear thinning risk if lower-quality	Quality of VII matters; premium synthetics minimize shear loss
Fuel economy	Slightly better	Slightly worse	Higher viscosity increases mechanical drag
Turbo/track protection	Adequate for most OEM duty	Better for sustained extreme duty	Margin of safety for bearing film and thermal stress
Engine wear in high-mileage engines	OK; may leak less	Often better oil pressure and fill of clearances	Can reduce rattling/consumption in worn engines
Seal & component compatibility	High	High (but check old rubber types)	Rare seal issues—check OEM guidance for classics
Typical recommended climate	Temperate / cold to warm	Hot climates / extreme duty	Use 50 where sustained high temps encountered

(Numbers are typical engineering ranges; exact HTHS and kinematic values vary by formulation and manufacturer.)

Best-fit use cases by driving style & climate

Driving style / climate	Prefer 5W-40?	Prefer 5W-50?	Notes
Daily commuting, mixed city/highway, temperate climates (−20 to +30 °C)	✅	❌	Better fuel economy; 5W-40 adequate
Cold climates (min < −25 °C)	✅	❌	Same cold flow; 5W-40 favored to avoid extra drag
Hot climates (daytime > 35–40 °C) with normal use	✅ (unless heavy load)	✅ if sustained high oil temps	For stop-start heat soak, 5W-40 OK; for constant heavy load prefer 5W-50
Track / high-RPM frequent sessions	❌ (unless high-quality 40 with high HTHS)	✅	5W-50 increases film margin
Heavy towing / high payload	❌ (unless short duration)	✅	Towing produces prolonged high load; 50 preferred
High-boost aftermarket turbo engines	❌ (unless OEM allows)	✅	50 helps with film and oil coking margins
High-mileage engines (>150k km/miles) with higher clearances	❌	✅	50 can restore oil pressure and reduce rattles
Manufacturer explicitly specifies 5W-40 or lower	❌	❌ (avoid)	Stay with OEM for warranty unless manufacturer permits higher grade

---

How to decide for your vehicle — decision checklist

Choose 5W-50 if and only if all of the following apply:

• Your OEM explicitly allows 5W-50 or a viscosity range that includes it, or you accept potential warranty risk; and
• You run sustained high oil temperatures (e.g., track days, extended towing, repeated high-boost use) — think oil bulk temps routinely above ~120 °C / bearing surfaces seeing high shear; or
• Your engine is high-mileage with increased clearances and you need improved oil pressure / reduced noise.

Choose 5W-40 if:

• Your driving is normal daily use, mixed highway/city, or cold climates; and
• OEM specifies 5W-40 (or does not authorize 50); and
• Fuel economy and emissions control (oxidation/DPF/aftertreatment compatibility) are priorities.

Risk & warranty warnings

• Always check OEM service manual: some modern engines (factory-built tight-tolerance turbocharged engines or those with variable valve timing phasing) require specific HTHS or synthetic types (and some explicitly disallow higher viscosities). Using a grade outside OEM recommendations may void warranty or cause issues with variable-geometry timing systems or electronic oil pressure regulation.
• Aftermarket modifications: if the engine is modified (higher compression, increased boost), OEM specs no longer fully apply; using 5W-50 may be necessary, but ensure your oil meets appropriate API/ACEA and OEM/engineering limits.
• DPF (diesel particulate filter) and emissions: some diesel engine oils optimized for DPF service have low ash formulations; moving to a heavier passenger-car oil without appropriate low-SAPs could harm aftertreatment. Match ACEA/API ratings.
• Seal compatibility: rare with modern oils, but for classic engines check elastomer compatibility or consider oils formulated for vintage cars.

Suggested certifications & specifications to look for

• Passenger petrol engines: API SP (or latest); ACEA A3/B4 for high-performance gasoline/diesel passenger cars (note ACEA class must match engine type).
• Turbodiesels with aftertreatment: ACEA C3 (low-ash), manufacturer OEM approvals (VW 504/507, MB-Approval 229.51/229.52, etc.—match your OEM).
• High-performance / high HTHS needs: look for explicit HTHS values listed by the supplier (e.g., ≥4.0 mPa·s for 50-grade targets) and shear-stability data.
• Oil for extended drain/track: formulations meeting OEM long-life specs (e.g., Porsche A40, BMW Longlife) if applicable.

(Match the certification to your engine type — petrol vs diesel vs performance; OEM approvals supersede generic API/ACEA.)

Top product categories to consider (no brand endorsements)

• Full-synthetic PAO + ester blends — best high-temp stability, shear resistance, turbo protection. (Use for track/high-boost/towing.)
• Group III hydrocracked synthetics — very good, cost-effective, reliable for most modern engines.
• Low-SAP (low ash, low-SulfatedAsh/Phosphorus/Sulfur) — required for modern DPF-equipped diesels and some gasoline direct-injection engines.
• High HTHS performance formulations — products that publish HTHS values and have proven shear stability (seek technical data sheets).

Practical, actionable recommendation (concise)

• If you drive normally (daily city/highway), live in temperate or cold climates, and/or your OEM specifies 5W-40 or a lower target → Use 5W-40. (Recommendation: 5W-40 — NO to 5W-50.)
• If you race frequently, track regularly, tow heavy loads in hot climates, operate a heavily modified/high-boost turbo, or have a high-mileage worn engine with low oil pressure → Use 5W-50, provided your OEM allows or warranty concerns are acceptable. (Recommendation: 5W-50 — YES only under these conditions.)

Example scenario (how I would answer if you gave vehicle data)

• Modern turbocharged 2018 BMW M340i (daily + weekly track): I would recommend 5W-50 for track sessions and 5W-40 for daily (or a deliberate switch to a high-quality 5W-50 that meets BMW LL-specified approval if BMW permits). Verify BMW LL approval.
• 2012 economy hatchback, 150k km, daily commuting in continental winter: 5W-40 to preserve fuel economy and cold start; consider 5W-50 only if oil pressure is low and compression/clearances high.

(If you give me your exact vehicle and duty cycle now, I will produce a single definitive yes/no recommendation and the exact rationale tailored to your engine and OEM specs.)

Closing notes on measurement & verification

• Inspect TD (technical data sheet) for HTHS, kinematic viscosity @100 °C, vi values, and oxidation/shear test results. The numbers tell the story: prefer oils that publish HTHS and show low shear loss after standardized tests.
• For track or towing, monitor oil temperature (target <130–140 °C for sustained operation) and oil pressure; if oil temps exceed safe thresholds, upgrading grade alone may not be enough—cooling, oil coolers, or reduced duty may be required.
• Change intervals: heavier duty and higher temps justify shorter drain intervals even with synthetic oils.