Removing the check engine light. Is it illegal?

The infamous “check engine light” – known to some as the Malfunction Indicator Lamp (MIL) – plays a crucial role as an early warning system in vehicles.

It alerts drivers to any potential problems with the engine or emissions control system, which, if left unaddressed, could lead to serious malfunctions.

Contrary to popular belief, removing the check engine light is not always illegal. The legality of doing so depends on the jurisdiction and the circumstances surrounding the issue.

For instance, if the root cause of the warning light has been fixed, and the vehicle is functioning as it should, then turning off the check engine light becomes justifiable.

After all, the purpose of the light is to indicate a problem and if the issue is resolved, the light serves no purpose. Sometimes, the light will turn off automatically after a short period of time when driving, but if it doesn’t, a diagnostic scan tool or mechanic can reset the code easily and turn it off.

However, if the check engine light is turned off without fixing the underlying issue, it could be viewed as tampering with emissions control equipment – a practice that is illegal in several states.

This form of tampering could lead to decreased fuel efficiency, increased emissions, and other performance issues. And in states where emissions tests are mandatory for vehicle registration renewal, tampering with the check engine light could result in a failed emissions test and penalties.

Additionally, selling or installing devices that disable or remove the check engine light is also illegal. These devices may be used to conceal emissions problems, thereby avoiding any consequences of not repairing them.

This can result in serious problems when registering the car and other penalties that the seller could suffer.

Some penalties for removing the “check engine light”

Removing the check engine light, or tampering with emissions control devices, could result in severe penalties across international jurisdictions. From fines to jail time, the consequences of violating the law can be severe. Let’s explore some key examples:

In the United States, the Clean Air Act (CAA) regulates air emissions from mobile sources, including vehicles. The CAA declares it illegal to tamper with, remove, or disable any emissions control device, including the check engine light.

Those who violate the CAA could face fines of up to $37,500 per violation, with a possible sentence of up to two years in jail.

The European Union (EU) has its own set of emissions standards for vehicles sold in its member countries. EU law prohibits removing the check engine light or tampering with any emissions control device.

Penalties for violating EU emissions standards can include fines and other penalties, and in some cases, the vehicle may be banned from being driven or sold.

UNECE regulations, set by the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, dictate global standards for the automotive industry, including emissions standards.

UNECE regulations make it illegal to remove the check engine light or tamper with any emissions control device. Penalties for violating these regulations can include fines and penalties, and in some cases, the vehicle may be banned from being driven or sold.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the legality of removing the check engine light is dependent on the country’s legislation. However, it’s best to avoid any legal and performance issues by addressing the root cause of the warning light and having it fixed by a professional.

In summary, the penalties for removing the check engine light or tampering with emissions control devices are serious and can vary depending on the jurisdiction.

It’s essential to abide by relevant laws and regulations to avoid these consequences, which can range from fines to jail time.

Scroll to Top